Should You Sell on UK Marketplaces Beyond Amazon? A Straight Comparison
Amazon dominates UK seller revenue, but spreading across multiple marketplaces can reduce platform risk and improve margins. This guide compares the real costs and benefits of DTC, TikTok Shop, and retail marketplaces for UK brands.
Most brands selling in the UK ask a version of the same question eventually. Amazon's working, revenue is solid, but there's a nagging feeling that one platform shouldn't be this much of the whole picture. So do you open up a DTC site? Is TikTok Shop actually serious now? What about the supermarkets and department stores that have quietly built out their own marketplace offerings? And if you spread yourself across multiple channels, does the operational headache just eat the margin gains?
I've been through this with Martian Made, my own sleep brand, and I think the honest answer is messier than most multichannel content suggests. So let me lay it out properly.
Amazon: the baseline
Amazon gives you distribution, trust, and fulfilment infrastructure that would cost you a fortune to replicate yourself. FBA means a customer in Aberdeen gets next-day delivery without you owning a single square foot of warehouse space. That is genuinely difficult to argue with.
The trade-off is obvious. You do not own the customer. You cannot email them, you cannot retarget them, and if Amazon decides your account has a problem, your revenue can disappear before you've had breakfast. The fees have shifted around a bit in 2026, with referral fee cuts in some categories and then a 1.5% fuel and logistics surcharge dropped in from April, so the savings were partially handed straight back. The margin on Amazon is real but it requires constant watching. Let it drift and it just quietly gets worse.
The other thing worth being straight about: 67% of active seller storefronts on Amazon UK are registered in mainland China. You are not competing on a level field, and that is not going to change. The brands that do well here build enough of a brand moat that price comparison becomes less of the decision.
On the question of platform exposure, Amazon is significant. One suspension, one policy change, one competitor gaming your listing and you are scrambling. It happens. I've dealt with it.
DTC on Shopify: the brand ownership argument
Running your own Shopify site gets you something Amazon can never give you: the customer relationship. You get the email address, the purchase history, the ability to run a proper post-purchase sequence, build loyalty, and work on customer lifetime value in a way that meaningfully changes your unit economics over time.
That case is real and I believe it. But it comes with a cost that people routinely underestimate.
Without Amazon's built-in traffic, you are buying every single customer yourself, mostly through paid social and Google. Customer acquisition costs in competitive categories are punishing right now, and the sleep and home space is not cheap. Your contribution margin on DTC needs to absorb fulfilment, returns, payment processing, platform fees, and whatever it costs to get someone to your site in the first place. For a lot of brands, the actual margin per order ends up being thinner than Amazon despite the higher revenue-per-sale.
Where DTC earns its keep is in repeat purchase economics. If you can get someone back for a second and third order without paying acquisition cost again, the numbers start to look very different. Email, SMS, and a genuinely good product are the whole game here. But that takes time to build, and it assumes your product has a natural repurchase cycle.
Control is high. Margin potential is high. But so is the cost of getting it wrong, and a two-person team building DTC from scratch while managing Amazon simultaneously is going to find one of them suffers.
TikTok Shop: past the novelty stage
I'll be honest, eighteen months ago I wasn't taking TikTok Shop seriously as an infrastructure play. I was wrong about that. It has grown fast enough in the UK that treating it as a social media side project is no longer the right frame.
TikTok Shop now has its own fulfilment option through Fulfilled by TikTok. For the sleep and home category specifically, where visual content and the kind of sensory demonstration that works well in short video has real purchase intent behind it, it has moved into territory worth genuine consideration. The Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2025 period saw 50% year-on-year sales growth on the platform, with 300,000 UK small businesses on it by September 2026.
The customer ownership picture is somewhere between Amazon and DTC. You have more visibility into your buyers than Amazon gives you, but you are still platform-dependent, and TikTok Shop is a relatively young infrastructure in the UK. The regulatory risk is different from Amazon's, but it exists. The commission rates are lower than Amazon's referral fees in a number of categories, which matters.
What TikTok Shop actually demands is content. Not ads in the traditional sense, but a consistent flow of product video, ideally with creator partnerships or LIVE commerce. If you do not have the capacity to produce that, or the kind of product that demonstrates well on video, you will spend energy here without getting much back. A pillow, actually, demonstrates very well. A data analytics service does not.
The margin control is reasonable. The fulfilment infrastructure is maturing. The operational overhead is content rather than logistics. For a brand with the right product and the right capacity, this is a real channel now.
Retail marketplaces: small individually, not small collectively
Here is where most multichannel conversations stop, and probably shouldn't. Tesco, Debenhams, B&Q, Next, Argos, and a growing number of other UK retailers have built out their own marketplace offerings over the last few years. Individually, none of them is going to move the needle the way Amazon does. Collectively, they add up to something worth thinking about.
What they offer that Amazon doesn't is brand association. Sitting alongside products on the Tesco or Debenhams website carries a different kind of consumer trust signal, particularly for premium brands that are trying to justify a higher price point. It is a subtle thing, but it is real. A customer who finds you on a platform they already trust for grocery or homewares has done a different kind of vetting than one scrolling through Amazon search results at midnight.
The operational picture has changed, too. Most of these retail marketplaces are now accessible through connector platforms like Linnworks or Mirakl, which means you are not building a separate integration from scratch for each one. You push your product data, pricing and inventory through a single middleware layer and the individual marketplace picks it up. That does not make it zero effort, but it makes it manageable in a way it wasn't three or four years ago.
The things to watch: each marketplace has its own content requirements, its own commission structure, and its own fulfilment expectations. Some will want you to hold stock in specific arrangements. Some have approval processes that take longer than you would expect. The margin per channel needs to be modelled individually, because a 12% commission on a Debenhams sale hits differently than the same rate on Amazon once you factor in the different fee structures, returns rates, and customer behaviour on each platform.
These channels also tend to be slower to build. Amazon rewards aggressive optimisation quickly. Retail marketplace traffic builds more gradually, partly because the marketplaces themselves are still developing the discovery tools that would send buyers your way. You are not going to replace Amazon volume here. What you are doing is adding brand exposure, a different type of customer relationship, and a modest revenue layer that is not sitting on the same platform risk as everything else.
If you are already using Linnworks or a similar inventory management system, the barrier to listing on one or two of these is lower than it probably feels. If you are not, adding that infrastructure has value beyond the retail marketplaces anyway, so the cost is partly shared.
So who should do what
A brand at seven figures with warehouse space, a small team, and an established product with strong repeat purchase potential should probably be running all of the above in some form, with Amazon as the volume engine, DTC as the margin and loyalty play, TikTok Shop tested properly rather than dabbled with, and one or two retail marketplaces added through a connector to spread platform risk and pick up the brand association benefit.
A two-person brand that has Amazon working should almost certainly get DTC properly functional before adding a third channel. The email list and the ability to own the customer conversation is the infrastructure that makes everything else more valuable later.
If your product is highly visual, demonstrates well, and you have any capacity for content creation, I'd put TikTok Shop higher up the priority list than conventional wisdom had it six months ago. The window where it costs less to grow there than Amazon is probably not permanent.
Retail marketplaces are worth a serious look if you are already running a connector platform, or if your brand has a premium positioning that benefits from the association. They are not the priority for a brand still finding its feet on Amazon. But for an established brand managing platform concentration risk, they are one of the more underused tools available.
What I would not do is spread across all of these simultaneously without the team to manage it. Being mediocre across five channels is worse than being serious about two.